The impact of war, February – March 2022

Source: Pixabay

Russia invaded Ukraine on Thursday 24 February. This followed several weeks when it was apparent that Russia had mobilised an army on its borders with Ukraine. In my view this is a significant historic event and is a humanitarian disaster, but I’m going to concentrate on the personal financial and portfolio impact of it in this post.

Rollercoaster

The Guardian reported a “rollercoaster day for shares after Russia hit with sanctions over Ukraine” and added that “the FTSE 100 index of Britain’s top 100 companies dropped 2% before finishing the day back where it started at 7,458 points.”

As at the end of February the investment return on my portfolio was -1.28% for the year so far. As at 18 March my investment returns look about the same. Those results mask a lot of volatile share price movements on a day-to-day basis. Share prices have moved by more than 2% up or down on individual days. I have to say that I try not to pay too much attention to daily market moves and that looks to have been the right thing to do. One holding, that I categorise as a growth trust, was 18% down for the year on 8 March but has now recovered to be 9% down as it was at the end of February and as it was on 23 February (see growth trust graph). Another holding, that I categorise as an income trust, was 14% down for the year on 7 March but is now only 3% down. It was 1% down on 28 February and 2% down on 23 February (see income trust graph). Of course, these share prices may move down again in the next few days.

February

The FTSE All Share Total Return index, my chosen benchmark, was down by -0.47% for the month, and down by -0.80% for the year so far. My investment return for the month was a loss of -1.23%, and a loss of -1.28% for the year so far. My individual holdings recorded share price movements for the year so far ranging from a loss of -20.31% to a gain of +2.60% with an unweighted average result of a loss of -3.44%. My worst performers were my growth holdings especially those that I have recently been adding to. My recent moves have thus worsened my results for the year so far. My better performers were some of my income holdings that will have high exposure to value stocks.

Capital

Starting from an index value of 100.00 at 31 December 2013, my capital is now 137.89, as shown in the graph above. There has been a reduction of -1.64% since December’s peak of 140.19. Investment return of a capital loss of -2.31% and dividend income of +1.03%, totalled a loss of -1.28%. Draw down expenditure deducted -0.36% during the year so far.

Income

Annual dividend income as a percentage of the opening portfolio value on 31 December 2013 has increased from 3.37% to reach 6.77% at this month end, as shown in the graph above. This is a new peak. It has been in a range between 6.65% and 6.77% since last March as I have tilted the portfolio away from income growth and towards capital growth. My current portfolio dividend income yield is 4.91%, i.e., 6.77 divided by 137.89.

Investment changes

Some dividends were received and re-invested during the month in my tax-sheltered accounts. Dividends in my dealing account were paid out to my bank. I also made two small switches reducing some global and UK equity income holdings and adding to some Asia Pacific and UK small company holdings. My growth holdings are now 13.14% of my portfolio compared to 7.81% twelve months ago. This is the after nine such small investment switches made since March last year.

Portfolio

The table below shows the composition of my portfolio at the end of the month. This has been analysed by the income or growth category of each holding.

Yield %Capital %Income %
High Income7.6725.5039.83
Income4.6246.7944.04
Income & Growth3.9913.2410.76
Growth1.9913.145.32
Cash0.191.330.05
4.91100.00100.00

Cash

My annual drawdown spending is now around 3.26% of my portfolio value, based on the last two years spending and the opening and closing values for that period. My cash holdings are sufficient to cover about four months of spending. In addition, dividends being paid out in cash each year from my dealing account are sufficient to cover about four months of spending. I will need to sell shares from my dealing account to raise cash in the next few weeks. My intention is to raise cash to spend and cash to fund the next tax year’s ISA just before the end of the current tax year. Given the volatility in share prices I may suffer lower prices on the day or days I sell.

Expenditure

Draw down spending was 61.78% of my portfolio income in the last twelve months which was an increase from 56.59% for the previous twelve months. Portfolio income rose by only 0.04% but expenditure rose by 9.22%. This increased spending resulted from some discretionary spending choices on electrical goods, furniture, and dining out (post lockdown), and exceptional costs on car repairs. There have been no impacts yet from the expected rises in energy costs, grocery bills and council taxes despite RPI and CPI inflation reaching annual rates of 7.84% and 5.41% at the end of January.

Having had both of my previous utility suppliers go bust last September just after I switched has meant that I waited five months for a refund for overpayments from last summer, whilst my new supplier has not yet charged me. We have not paid for any gas or electricity since December but I am expecting a large bill to appear as well as the expected big rise in prices. The new Council Tax year starts soon and it looks like there will be a 4.1% increase. Our grocery costs have actually fallen, probably because we bought more during lockdown in the previous year. The cost-of-living crisis has yet to hit us but as and when it does, we will be not too badly placed. Probably less than half of our spending can be classed as essential so we have discretionary and luxury spending that we are prepared to reduce if we need to.

Conclusion

So far, the impact of this war on my personal finances and portfolio has been to increase share price volatility and to increase uncertainty about the future. That hasn’t led to any significant loss of capital. This all feels fairly minor and trivial when looking at the major tragedy unfolding elsewhere in Europe, in Ukraine.

More or less flat, January 2022

Source: Pixabay

As at Friday (28th January) my portfolio was down only 1.23% for the year so far, and about 0.22% of that was drawdown spending. A 1.01% fall is like one bad day so nothing to get too excited about for me and my portfolio. Monday (31st January) was then a better day so the month’s return was actually flat. Moneyweek reported “that even as the over-priced US stock market gyrated all over the place in January – and ended the month significantly down – the FTSE 100 ended up more or less flat.” That FTSE 100 result reflected my own portfolio results for January.

January

The FTSE All Share Total Return index, my chosen benchmark, was down by -0.33% in the month. My investment return for the month was a loss of -0.05%. My individual holdings recorded share price movements for the month ranging from a loss of -14.02% to a gain of +5.26% with an unweighted average result of a loss of -1.06%. My worst performers were the growth holdings in UK and Asia Pacific smaller companies that I have recently been adding to. My better performers were my UK equity income holdings that will have high exposure to value stocks. My high yield bond holding was unchanged.

Capital

Starting from an index value of 100.00 at 31 December 2013, my capital is now 139.83, as shown in the graph above. There has been a small reduction of -0.26% since last month’s peak of 140.19. Investment return of a capital loss of -0.28% and dividend income of +0.23%, totalled a loss of -0.05%. Draw down expenditure deducted -0.21% during the month.

Income

Annual dividend income as a percentage of the opening portfolio value on 31 December 2013 has increased from 3.37% to reach 6.74% at this month end, as shown in the graph above. This is slightly below last November’s peak of 6.75%.

Investment changes

Some dividends were received and re-invested during the month in my tax-sheltered accounts. Dividends in my dealing account were paid out to my bank. No other trades were made.

Portfolio

The table below shows the composition of my portfolio at the end of the month. This has been analysed by the sector of each holding.

Yield %Capital %Income %
UK4.0040.8533.91
Asia Pacific4.8823.7524.05
Global4.3817.5115.92
Property6.978.6012.43
Bonds8.018.2113.63
Cash0.271.090.06
4.82100.00100.00

I have also analysed by the income or growth category of each holding.

Yield %Capital %Income %
High Income7.4826.0940.45
Income4.5447.3044.51
Income & Growth3.9113.3210.80
Growth1.6512.214.18
Cash0.271.090.06
4.82100.00100.00

Cash

My annual drawdown spending is now around 3.23% of my portfolio value, based on the last two years spending and the opening and closing values for that period. My cash holdings are sufficient to cover about four months of spending. In addition, dividends being paid out in cash each year from my dealing account are sufficient to cover about four months of spending. I will need to sell shares from my dealing account to raise cash in the next few weeks.

Expenditure

Draw down spending was 64.08% of my portfolio income in the last twelve months which was an increase from 58.69% for the previous twelve months. Portfolio income rose by only 1.66% but expenditure rose by 11.00%. This increased spending resulted from some discretionary spending choices and some exceptional cost items. There have been no impacts yet from the expected rises in energy costs, grocery bills and council taxes despite RPI and CPI inflation reaching annual rates of 7.55% and 5.40% at the end of December.

Conclusion

I find that I haven’t been personally impacted by the headlines of stock market falls and inflation rises that I read. Not so far at least.

The Santa rally, December 2021

Source: Pixabay

The headline after the stock market closed on Christmas eve read “‘Santa rally’ sees FTSE 100 hit 22-month high on Omicron optimism.” The article then stated that “data suggesting the variant is not as severe as feared pushes index close to pre-pandemic levels.”

A week later on reviewing my portfolio for the month of December I concluded that the Santa rally had delivered for me. Half of my (unrealised) capital gains for the year were made in December. The month was the best of the year since we had similar gains in March and April. In my portfolio 94% of my total gain for the year was made in those three months.

December

The FTSE All Share Total Return index, my chosen benchmark, was up by +4.68% in the month, and is up by +18.32% for the year to date. My investment return for the month was a gain of +3.95%, and I have a gain of +13.94% for the year to date. My individual holdings recorded share price movements for the year ranging from a loss of -9.65% to a gain of +45.17% with an unweighted average result of a gain of +12.43%.

My best performers were in commercial property with average share price gains of 29.50%. My UK holdings made share price gains between 4.80% and 25.06% with an unweighted average of 13.44%. That is just below the capital gain of 14.60% from the FTSE All Share index. My international and bond holdings detracted from my overall results. The share price of my bond holding rose by 7.31%. My Asia Pacific and global holdings recorded share price movements between a loss of -9.65% and a gain of 28.05% with an unweighted average of 6.41%.

My UK dividend income return will have exceeded the 3.72% income return on the FTSE All Share index and allowing for the fees payable on a UK index tracker fund then I believe that total returns on my UK holdings have near enough matched the total return on the UK index. If we include my property and bonds then the 57% of my portfolio I have invested in the UK, and in property and bonds has beaten the UK index, but the 42% invested in Asia Pacific and global holdings has not.

Capital

Starting from an index value of 100.00 at 31 December 2013, my capital is now 140.19, as shown in the graph above. This is a new peak. It is up by +10.35% for the 2021 year. Investment returns, growth (+8.33%) and income (+5.38%), added +13.71%, and draw down expenditure deducted -3.36% during the 2021 year.

Income

Annual dividend income as a percentage of the opening portfolio value on 31 December 2013 has increased from 3.37% to reach 6.74% at this month end, as shown in the graph above. This is a tiny fall from last month’s peak, and arises from the investment changes mentioned below, but is still a doubling of the starting income eight years ago. Portfolio income has increased by 4.14% in the year to date.

Investment changes

Some of last month’s dividends were re-invested early in the month. Also, in early December I sold part of an “income” holding in order to add to a “growth” holding. This is part of my gradual switch towards growth.

Portfolio

The table below shows the composition of my portfolio at the end of the month. This has been analysed by the sector of each holding.

Yield %Capital %Income %
UK4.0340.4233.87
Asia Pacific4.8723.4423.73
Global4.3218.2116.37
Bonds8.018.1813.64
Property6.918.5812.34
Cash0.211.160.05
4.81100.00100.00

I have also analysed by the income or growth category of each holding.

Yield %Sectors
High Incomeabove 5%Property, Bonds, Asia Pacific, UK
Income4% to 5%UK, Global, Asia Pacific
Income & Growth3% to 4%Asia Pacific, Global
Growthbelow 3%UK, Asia Pacific

Yield %Capital %Income %
High Income7.4525.9840.29
Income4.6246.8645.07
Income & Growth3.7713.4610.56
Growth1.5412.544.03
Cash0.211.160.05
4.81100.00100.00

This allocation has changed, again, since last month as some holdings have moved from the higher income to the income category because their share price rose. My holdings in the growth category have grown from 8.06% to 12.54% of my portfolio over the last twelve months.

Cash

My annual drawdown spending is now around 3.36% of my portfolio value, based on the last two years spending and the opening and closing values for that period. My cash holdings are sufficient to cover about five months of spending. In addition, dividends being paid out in cash each year from my dealing account are sufficient to cover about four months of spending. Most of my dividends are being reinvested in my tax-sheltered accounts. I last sold shares from my dealing account to raise cash in early September. I will need to do that again in the next few months.

Expenditure

Draw down spending was 63.67% of my portfolio income in the year to 31 December 2021 which was an increase from 62.54% for the previous year. Portfolio income rose by 6.66% and expenditure rose by 8.60%. This increased spending represents exceptional items and spending choices and fewer restrictions but not yet higher inflation.

Our energy costs have not risen significantly yet as our energy company transfer away from our failed provider has still not completed. Our grocery costs are slightly lower than the previous year. I expect both to rise along with Council Tax.

Conclusion

I’m pleased with the progress of my investment portfolio this year. Total returns were in double figures even after deducting draw down spending. I achieved a balance of an increase in portfolio income and a slight shift towards owning more holdings seeking growth. It would have been nice to have beaten the UK index too but it’s not essential for me to do that every year.

My alternatives to equities

Current portfolio

I have over 80% of my investment portfolio in equities (company shares) and only around 2% in cash and I hold the balance in bonds and property. I’m now going to explain how I arrived at that position and how that is working for me.

Yield %Capital %Income %
Equities4.5481.6574.23
Bonds8.228.1313.38
Property7.218.5412.33
Cash0.191.680.06
4.99100.00100.00

My journey

When I first invested in equities in 1986, I kept a large proportion of my assets in cash because that cash was my rainy-day fund – my three, six or twelve months of spending held in reserve. On average I kept 30% in cash and on average that was about half of my net salary. As I built up my equity savings, including PEP’s when they started, the proportion of my money in cash fell. As I moved home twice in the ten years after 1986 and changed jobs twice including a redundancy it was useful to have surplus cash. Also, interest rates were more generous (and exceeded dividend yields).

By the late 1990’s I began to consider my asset allocation and by coincidence I read a book, The Fortune in Your Future by David C Veeneman, that considered some model portfolios. The book explored eleven model portfolios along a so-called efficient frontier. My preference was for the “partly cloudy” portfolio that had 79% in equities, 1% in bonds, and 20% in stable values. This was described as “a portfolio for investors who want a good return and can tolerate occasional setbacks”. I chose to interpret the portfolio allocations as 80% in equities and 20% in cash.

My portfolio roughly kept to that for the next ten years with on average 22% in cash. This will have mitigated my losses in the dot come boom and bust era. When interest rates were massively reduced in 2008, I felt it was time to reduce my cash which now represented over twice my net salary. I bought more shares and then my shares rose in price so my cash position fell from about 22% in 2007 to around 12% in 2009. I held that position for the next five years.

On ending my last job at the end of 2013, I again considered my portfolio allocation. I had only 9% in cash but I took the view that I still had too much cash given the poor returns from the low interest rates in early 2014. Cash has become trash in offering no meaningful return. Its value was in providing liquidity and stable values so long as inflation remained very low. As I began to focus more on the amount of income generated by my portfolio, I decided to put more cash into equities to drive up my income. Having invested through the stock market falls of 1987, 2001-2002, and 2008 I felt that my ability to handle equity risk was sufficient to be able to hold more equities. I then moved to have over 95% in equities and less than 5% in cash during 2014.

My next move was in early 2017 when I decided to diversify for the first time into high-yield bonds and commercial property REIT’s. This was a tactic to increase again my portfolio income but also to diversify away from the pure equities of company shares. This also reflected the idea of reducing such equity exposure as you get older. Over the next three years, I built up a position of nearly 18% in these assets. About half of that was in an investment trust that held over one hundred high-yield bonds. Its objective then was “to provide investors with a high dividend yield and the potential for capital growth by investing mainly in high yielding fixed interest securities”. The accounts of the trust at that time indicated that it had 132 holdings with the biggest one being only 3.2% of the portfolio. This gave me less risk than holding an individual corporate bond or retail bond. The other half was in a commercial property REIT investment trust that held over one hundred properties. Its factsheet then said that it had a “highly diversified regional UK office and industrial portfolio” of 128 properties, comprising 974 units, and with 719 tenants. This gave me less risk than holding an individual property with an individual tenant, and didn’t require as much of a financial commitment.

I have kept those holdings since then, both in tax sheltered accounts, with their dividends being reinvested in more shares. The only change in early 2021 was to sell half of the commercial property REIT in order to buy into a rival commercial property REIT. As I’ve previously reported that new holding has since been re-rated and is now my top performer of 2021.

Selected years

DateEquity %Cash %Bonds %Property %
Dec-85100.00
Dec-8754.0245.98
Dec-9269.0031.00
Dec-9877.9422.06
Dec-0778.0221.98
Dec-0988.1911.81
Dec-1390.739.27
Dec-1495.294.71
Dec-1698.431.57
Dec-1980.391.848.449.32

My recent results

Return per annum (XIRR)TotalCapitalIncome
Total6.19%-1.65%7.72%
Bonds5.41%-2.54%7.75%
Property6.89%-0.87%7.69%

I have reviewed the total return on these non-equity holdings for the nearly five years I have been invested in them. I have allowed for the time invested, the gain or loss in the share price, and the dividends received. I calculated an internal rate of return (XIRR using an excel spreadsheet). This gave an overall result of 6.19% per annum. There has been some decline in capital values of -1.65% per annum but the income return has been 7.72% per annum. In simpler terms the amount invested has grown in total by 25.46%, comprising 32.46% from dividends received less -7.01% from share price falls.

InvestedDividendsCapitalCurrent Value
Total100.0032.46-7.01125.46
Bonds100.0030.61-9.96120.65
Property100.0034.36-3.96130.40

That 6.19% total return for these assets is close to my rough calculation of 6.10% compound growth for my total portfolio from February 2017 to November 2021. So, I have matched my equity returns and exceeded the returns available on cash. There has been significant volatility so these assets have more risk than cash and maybe more risk than equities. Certainly, the bond trust and the property trust fell significantly in March 2020. I believe they have given me more diversity whilst they have increased my portfolio yield. The current yield is 7.70%.

The future

At present these holdings of bonds and property are useful as a means of raising the level of income in the portfolio in that they provide one-quarter of the income from only one-sixth of the capital. This assists me in moving some of the equity holdings from income trusts to small company growth trusts. Going forward I am likely to maintain these investments but I can envisage in the longer term reducing their position sizes, or switching them to lower yielding alternatives, as I increasingly prioritise growth over income. I don’t plan to raise my cash levels significantly unless interest rates rise significantly so that there are some returns from cash.